CW Software Comparsions
This test is in purpose to show the performance difference inbetween softwares
I will use three lines of the exact same text
to exercise the effects of multipath.
"the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog" 44 possible mistakes letters plus spacing for one line 132 possible mistakes for three lines 396 possible mistakes for all three series of runs.
using this line should exercise every letter in the alphabet for long and short codes lengths.
I will do a three series of test to help rule out human error or computer hiccups
I use the same sound file for each run of tests.
I usually use MixW to acquire a baseline reading
I lower the SNR to the point were errors start showing up
in theory this should be edge of performance for most software and were you can
see some measurable differances.
I will give the error rate in % (rounded to nearest whole number) then give the over all average of the series of three runs then I will give
the over all performance of all test together.
I give the percentage of error after each test.
first test is 8wpm direct at -3DB SNR
Direct path with numerous softwares
MixW
AHE QUICK BRO MN FOX JUMPETE OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BRO MN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOM THE QUI RK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =11 or 8%
AHE QUICK BRO MN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BRO MN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOM THE QUI RK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =8 6%
AHE QUICK BRO MN FOX JUMPETE OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BRO MN FOX JUMPEN OVER THE LAZY DOM THE QUI RK BROWN FM X JUME NED OVER THE LAZY DOG =18 14%
Overall Average 9%
MultiPSK
ETA BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DO =4 3%
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0 0%
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0 0%
Over All Average 3%
FlDigi
5HE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE
LAZY DOM =3 or 2%
5HE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =1 or 1%
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK
BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0 or 0%
over all average 3%
DM780
TE C K *ROWN*OX *UMPEB IOVER 4HE *AZY LOG AHE QH*K *ROWN*OX *UMPED *VER UHE ELAZY *OG UHE UICK*ROWN*OX *UMPED JVELUHE *AZY OG =42 or 32%
*HE QUICK *ROWN*OX *UMPED *VER 4HE *AZY OG VHE QUICK *ROWN *OX 2UMPED *VER AHE *AZY *OG VHE *UICK*ROWN*OX *UMPED OVER UHE *AZY OG =27 or 20%
*HE UICK *ROWN*OX *UMPED JVER 4HE *AZY *OG UHE _UICK *ROWN*OX 2UMPED *VER AHE ELAZY *OG VHE *UICK*ROWN *OX *UMPED EOVER ETHE *AZY LOG =31 or 23%
over all average 25%
CWGet
the m uick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog =2 or 2%
tttteeck brown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog =6 or 5%
the guick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog =1 or 1%
over all average is 3%
MRP40
The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog =0 or 0%
The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog =0 or 0%
The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog =0
over all average 0%
13WPM Direct at -3db SNR
MixW
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OS ER THE LAZY DOG THE QETICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICN BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER TIEE LAZY DOG =7 or 5%
THE QUICK BROWN FT TX JUMPED OS ER THE LAZY DOG THE QETICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE DAZY DOG THE QUICN BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER TIEE LAZY DOG =12 or 9%
THE QUICK BROWN FT TX JUMPED OS ER THE LAZY DOG THE QETICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE DAZY DOG THE QUICN BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER TIEE LAZY DOG =12 or 9%
Total average = 16%
MultiPSK
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG = 0 or 0%
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG = 0 or 0%
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG = 0 or 0%
Over all average total= 0%
FLdigi
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0 or 0%
5HE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =1 or 1%
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0 or 0%
OVerall average .33%
DM780
*HE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK *ROWN <VE>OX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY OG THE EQUICK BROWN FOX EJUMPED OVER UHE LAZY DOG =11 or 8%
*THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK *ROWN <VE>OX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX EJUMPED OVER AHE LAZY DOG =9 or 7%
*HE QUICK BROWN FOX 2UMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX 2UMPED OVER THE LAZY LOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX EJUMPED OVER ETHE LAZY DOG =5 or 4%
Overall Average is 8%
CWget
the qieeeet brown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog =6 or 5%
the q.ieeat srown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog =6 or 5%
the qeeeaet brown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog =6 or 5%
over all average is 5%
MRP40
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG = 0
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG = 0
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG = 0
Overall average is 0%
18wpm at -3DB sNR direct path
MixW
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUT PE I OVEE E THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK TIROWN FM X JUT PED OVER THE LAZY DOG T SE QUICK BROWT FOX JUMPEN OVEE E THE LAZY DOG =22 or 17%
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUT PE I OVEE E THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK TIROWN FM X JUT PED OVER THE LAZY DOG T SE QUICK BROWT FOX JUMPEN OVEE E THE LAZY DOG =22 or 17%
HE QUICK BROWN FOX JUT PE I OVER THE LE ZY DOG THE QUICK TIROWN FM X JUT PED OVER THE LAZY DOG T SE QUICK BROWT FOX JUMPEN OVEE E THE LAZY IOG =21 or 16%
over all average 17%
MultiPSK
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
over all average =0%
FlDigi
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0
over all average 0%
DM780
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
0% over all
CWGet
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
over all 0%
MRP40
THe Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog =0
THe Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog =0
THe Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog =0
over all average =0
28wpm direct at -3DB SNR
MRP40
The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy TE Om Tie EQUInEEX Brown FTMXJUUÜESoVEEN The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped DTvEN The Lazy Dog =23 or 17%
The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy TE Om Tie EQUIDeX Brown InTMXJUItÜEE Dove EEE The Lazy Dog The Quit RKDrZWN Fot AJHMPE Dove N The Lazy Dog =37 or 28%
THe Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy TE Om TEEE Quick Brown veTM= Jumped OVEEN The Lazy Dog The Quit FKD Row N Fot A Jumped OVEN The LTZY Dog =25 or 19%
over all average 21%
MixW
HE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER HE LAZY DOG TS E QUICK BROWN FOX JUMW ED OVER THE LAZY DOG TH QUICK BROWN FOX JI MPED OVER THE R AZY DOG =11 or 8%
HE QUCK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER HE LAZY DT TG TS E QUICK BROWN FOX JUMW ED OVER THE LAZY DOG TH QUICK BROWN FOX JI MPED OVER THE R AZY DOG =16 or 12%
HE QUICK BOWN FOX JUMPED OVER HE LAZY DOG TS E QUICK BROWN FOX JUMW ED OVER THE LAZY DOG TH QUICK BROWN FOX JI MPED OVER THE R AZY DOG =10 or 8%
Over all average is 9%
DM780
HE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DT * THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =5 or 4%
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0 or 0%
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =1 or 1%
over all average is 2%
MultiPSK
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG
over all average is 0%
CWget
THE QUICn BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG TIIT QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =4 or 3%
THE QUIC ae t e teox JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICk BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =9 or 7%
THE QUICe e OX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG= 7 or 5%
over all average is 5%
FLDigi
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0
THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG THE QUICK BROWN FOX JUMPED OVER THE LAZY DOG =0
over all average is 0%
next test is Mid-Latitude Quiet -3db SNR at 27wpm
FLDigi
EHE QUICK T AWN FOX 6UMPED ?VEE THE LRZY DOG SE QUIC E BROVN FOX JUM<AS>ED 6 R TH LAZY DOG E SE QUICN BROW FOX WIMPED
OVER TE LAZY DOC =35 or 27%
5HE QUICK T AWN FOX 6UMPED ?VEE THE LRZY DOG SE QUIC E BROVN FOX JUG<AS>ED 6 R TH LAZY DOG SE QUICT BROW FOX
WIMPED OVER TE LAZY DOC =35 or 27%
5HE QUICK T AWN FOX 6UMPED ?VEE THE LRZY DOG SE QUIC E BROVN FOX JUM<AS>ED 6 R TH LAZY DOG E SE QUICN
BROW FOX WIMPED OVER TE LAZY DOC =34 or 26%
over all average is 27%
MixW
HE QUICK T
TWN FOX RE UMPED E TS
THE E I E EIY DO E
IE QUIC
SRT
N S TX JUT E EE
T
THE LAZY DOG IE M UICN
SROW FOX I
E PED OVER E
DAZY DOE =59 or 45%
E QUICK T
TWN FOX RE UMPED E TS
THE E I E EIY DO E
IE QUIC
SRT
N S TX JUT E EE
HE LAZY DOG IE M UICN
SE EOW FOX I
E PED OVER E
AZY DOE =75 or 57%
E QUICK T
TWN FOX RE UMPED E TS
THE E I E EIY DO E
IE QUIC
SRT
N S T TX JUT E EE
HE LAZY DOG IE M UICN
SE EOW FOX I
E PED OVER E
AZY DOE =76 or 58%
Over all average 53%
MultPSK
EHE UICK N E MWN FOX JUMPED IMVEEE THE LAZY DOG HE QUIC E BROWN FOX JUMPETI MR THE LAZY DOG THE QUICBROWE FOX WIMPED OVER TILAZY DOG =29 or 22%
EHE UICK N MWN FOX JUMPED IMVEEEE THE LAZY DOG EHE QUIC E BROWN FOX JUMPED R THE LAZY DOG TIE QUICBROWE FOX IMPED OVER TILAZY DOG =28 or 21%
EHE UICK N E MWN FOX JUMPED IMVEEE THE LAZY DOG EHE QUICE BROWN FOX JUMPED THE LAZY DOG TIE QUICBROWE FOX IMPED OVER TILAZY DOG =22 or 17%
Over all average is 20%
DM780
*TH XUICK T IEWN FOX JUMPED OVE5VHE LRZY DOG IHE QUIC I BROWN FOX JUMPED * EE* THE LAZY DOG THE QUICD BROWT FOX *UMPED OVER T5E LAZY DOG =24 or 18%
*HE QUICK N S WN FOX JUMPED OVEEHE THE LRZY DOG IHE QUIC E *ROWN FOX JUMPED B EIF THE LAZY DOG THE QUICD BROWT FOX *UMPED OVER T5E ELAZY DOG =25 or 19%
T HE QUICK T A WN FOX JUMPED OVE5VHE LRZY DOG IHE QUICE I BROWN FOX JUMPED 6 EE* THE LAZY DOG THE QUICD BROWT FOX WIHMPED OVER T<ERR>IELAZY DOG =30 or 23%
over all average is 20%
MRP40
IE Quick T EWN NoX EUMPEE TSE TS M DMI E QUIK SR N EMX JIt TI DaZY Dog TNTuICT TIROW FOX EI TPED MVER DaZY DoIE =66 or 50%
IE Quick T EWN NoX TuMPEE Tie TSE 3 DMI E QUIK BR N Wx JU Tie DaZY Dog TITuICT BROW FOX E TPED MVER DaZY DoEE =57 or 43%
EIE Quick T EWN NoX EUMPEEE IE TH Ü DMI E QUIB BR N Wx JU TI DaZY Dog E TNTuICN TIROW FOX E TPED MVER DaZY NoIEE =75 or 57%
over all average is 50%
CWget
the quicktem eo6 en tese ii te ttt y do e ee quite ee r i t tmx jit e th lazy e e e ertuicn teeerow ermi iu emteeti ittver t dazy doe
the quick t wt eo6 eeet the eeee t entt tw do e e qu i te eir te ox jit e th lazy e e tt met uicn t tt tteow fmi n n n mteeti ttver t dazy doi
tese quick t we eox ee e the iee t etee y do e e t quint tttt tn te ox jit e th lazy ei t nt t ttteecn t tt tteow fme e n n etteeti mver e dazy dos
lots and lots of errors.
Mid-Latitude Quiet -3db SNR at 18WPM
CWget
tese quit t noe a ttu ed o n the ade m t og t ci t breeeet t t n t tu aumee t t d z r tst t tda y dot ti q n e te i ne ttteoni en t a ttn over t eie i t te nam n e e
the quit n teo tu t e e d o n the ade at tt t tmg t ci t bree een e i tu aumi eed z en the la y dot ts q mnt e i ne tteit tmn e en t e tg over t se t tt nam ea e
tese quit n noe ee tetu e d o n the ag at ttt tmg t ci et bree eew tt te a tu aumi eed g r the la y dot ts q
mnt e i ne tteit tmn e en t e tg over t se t tt nam ea e
lots and lots of error not worth counting
DM780
T H E Q UIT IU BROWN FOX *UMPED O5* THE HAZY DOG THEIQ <ERR>CK BROWN <VE>OX EWUMAIED O*R THE LA5EY DOG ETHE Q EICK N E*WN FO6 PE *PED E OVER THE LAM EY *Z =55 or 42%
AHE QUIN IU BROWN FOX *UMPED O4* THE HAZY DOG THEIQ <ERR>CK BROWN <VE>OX EWUMAIED O*R THE LA<ERR>EY DOG ETHE _ EICK N E*WN FO6 *E <ERR>PE D E2 VER THE LAM EY *Z =66 or 50%
*HE QUIT * BROWN FOX 3U*ED O5* THE EHAZY DOG THE IQ <ERR>CK BROWN <VE>OX EWUMAIED OVIR THE LA<ERR>EY DOG AHE EQE IICK N E*WN FO6 *E *PED E OVER THE R AM EY *Z =59 or 45%
over all average is 46%
FLDigi
THE QUIT T DRORN FO U EMUUPD OS R THE IAZ3 BOG THE Q ICM BROWN FOX MUMI EED O ER THE LA EY DOG THE Q CK T OWN FOB W IAPEI OVER THE R AD EY SZB =51 or 39%
5HE QUIT T DRORN FO U EMUUPD OS R THE IAZ3 BOG THE Q ICM BROWN FOX E MUMI EED O ER THE LA EY DOG THE Q CK T OWN FOB W IAPEI OVER THE R TD EY SZ =52 or 39%
5HE QUIT T DRORN FO U EMUUPD OS R THE IAZ3 BOG THE Q ICM BROWN FOX E MUMI EED O ER THE LA EY DOG THE Q CK T OWN FOB W IAPEI OVER THE R TD EY SZD =55 or 42%
over all average is 40%
MixW
HE QUIN
BROIEEE FO ET E MU E E E ED O E R THE
AT E E T E IOG TEI ME
CE BROWN ROX E TUMI EED OE R THE LA
Y DOM THE Q E R T T
E N I EMT E
PE
OVER T IE R N DT E T E =76 or 58%
HE QUN BROIEEE FO ET E MU E E E ED O E R THE
AT E E T E IOG TEI ME
CE BROWN ROX E TUMI EED OE R THE LI Y DOME THE Q E R T T
E N I EMT E
EPE
OVER T IE R N DT E T E =93 or 70%
HE QUIN
BROIEEE FO ET E TU E E E ED O E R THE AT E E T E IOG TEI ME
CE BROWN ROX E TUMI EED O R THE LA
Y DOM THE Q E R T T
E N I EMT E
E W E
OVER T IE R N DT E T E =93 or 70%
over all average 66%
MultiPSK
HEQUIN A BROWN FOU EWUMPED OER THE AZY DOG THE Q ICK BROWN FOX E MUMAED OEEER THE LATEY DOG THE QE EICK N OWN FOX WIPETIOVER THE AEY DOM =32 or 24%
HEQUIN A BROWN FOIU EWUMPED OER THE AZY DOG THE Q ICK BROWN FOX E MUMAIED OEER THE LAEY DOG THE QE EICK N OWN FOX WIPETI OVER THE LAEY DOM =33 or 25%
HEQUIN A BROWN FOU EWUMPED OER THE IAZY DOG THE Q ICK BROWN FOX E MUMAED OEEER THE LAEY DOG THE QE EICK N OWN FOX WII PETIOVER THE LAMY DOE= 32 or 24%
over all average 24%
MRP40
THe Quit D ROAE N FO A MU ED G R The AG M EOG T E T C E BROWT NoX AUMA EED O R TEEE LA Y D Om TI Q I T T EItN E MT E P Over T SE T TT Nm =72 or 55%
AHe Quit D ROAE E FMT A MU ED G R The AG M EOG T E T C E BROWT NoX AUMA EED O R TEEE LA Y D Om TI Q EN T T TN E MT E P Over TSE I ET NM =72 or 55%
AHe Quit DrOAE N FO A MU ED G R The AZ W EOG T E T C E BROWT NoX AUMA EED O R TE E LA Y Don TI Q N T T ETN E MT P Over T SE T TT Nm =70 or 53%
over all average is 54%
Mid-Latitude Quiet -3db SNR at 13wpm
MixW
H E QI CK BRO E E E F EE U A AMW D ETI ER T I Z Y DOE E THE KU CK SROW FOB A TUE E N D
IA R H
DE E T DOT E E QE I E E
SR ME N EM U W UMW E N G
I E EEAZ W N G N =111 or 84%
HE QI CK BRO E E E EE A AMW D E TI ER T I Z Y DOE E THE KU CK SROW FOB A TUE E E D IA R H DE E T DOT E E QE I E R ME N EG U W UMP E N G
I E EEAZ W G N =104 or 79%
HE QI CK BRO E E E F EE U A AMW D E TI ER T I IZ Y DOE E THE KU CK SROW FOB A TUE E N D IA R H DE E T DOT E E QE I E
SR ME N EM U W UMP E N G
I E EEAZ W N G N =109 or 83%
Over all average is 82%
MultiPSK
TE QI CK BROVN FOX JUMD OVER THE AZY DOTTHE QU ECK BROWFOX JUATEED ETER HE LZY DOG IE QICT AETMETE N EENMV WEUMPED OAEEITSEE AIAGE EW NEMTG =58 or 44%
TE QI CK BON ETX JUMP D OVER THE AZY DOTHE QU ECK BROWFOX JUATEED ETER HE LZY DOG IEE QICT RTMETE N EENMU EMEUMPED OETEEI TSEE IAGE EW NEOG =60 or 45%
TE QI CK BRON FOX JUMD OVER THE AZY DOTHE QU ECK BROWFOX JUPED ETVER HE LZY DOME IEE QICT RTMETE N EENME U EMEUMPENE OETEEI TSEE IAGE EW NEMTG =60 or 45%
Over all average = 45%
FLDigi
THE QI CK BROAT FJX PUGW D YVER THE A TGY DOII THE QU CK BROW FO<BT> RTU RED -ER THE REZX DOD HE QHI-5R?A N NM U WUMW N O AEETIE 5AM W NOG =60 or 45%
5HE QI CK BROAT FJX PUGW D YVER THE A TGY DOII THE QU CK BROW FO<BT> RTU RED -ER THE REZX DOD ESE QHI-5R?A N NM U WUMW N O RETIE 5AM W NOG =66 50%
5HE QI CK BROAT FJX PUGW D YVER THE A TGY DOII THE QU CK BROW FO<BT> RTU RED -ER THE REZX DOD HE QHI-5R?A N NM U WUMW N O AEETIE 5AM W NOG =68 52%
over all average 49%
MRP40
AHe QI Ck BRO TT F TEX R AmW D AIEER The E GY DotI The ÄU Ck HRow FOD ATu N D Ever TH I ZTA DotE E QE I E SRÜA N Nm U W UMW T G TI E EIAG W T GG =95 or 72%
The QI Ck BRO TT F TEX R AmW D AIEER The E GY DotI The QU Ck HRow FOD ATu N D VER TH I ZTA DotE E QE I E SA WA N Nm U W UMW T G TI E EIAG W T OG =83 or 63%
The QI Ck BRO TT F TEX W AmW D MIEER The E GY DotI The QU Ck HRow FOb ATu N D VER TH I ZT A DotE E Q I SA WA N Nm U W UMW T G TI E E IAG W T GG =85 or 64%
Over ALL average is 66%
DM780
HE QI S<AR> K BROWNE*QX *UM*ID OVER THE AEUZY DOC UHE QU ECK *ROW*FOX 2UEI*ED *VER AHE *H ? T D O Z EUSI E Q V I * * R O W N <VE> M W EUMPED 2VE* T S E SD A G Y NE G =82 or 62%
T HE QI S<AR>K BROVN5FOX *UM*ID OVER THE F 4ZY DOC UHE QUICK *ROW*FOXI2UEI*ED *VEREAHE ERES U E E T O Z EUSI E Q II I ** * R O R N <VE>M 4 EUMW ED J** I U IE E SSI M TME Y NE O G =97 or 73%
H E Q I S<AR>K BROVN*OX *UMPID OVER THE F VZY DOC 4HE QU ECK *ROWII*OX JUH*ED E*4ER AH E FIH ? T D O Z EUSIE QHI* *ROR N <VE>M 4 WEUMPED 2VE*I TSEE *AZ NE O G =75 or 57%
over all errors is 64%
CWget had many many errors too many to even mention
Mid-Latitude Quiet +4Db SNR 8wpm
(i found that -3db caused way too many errors very hard to score)
MixW
E 5E T TUICK SROITN ROX J TMPED OEAER THE LAZY DOG HE QUICK BA OWN S EONT W UN PED D I TEE E TH LAZY DOG TES QUIEIEK T EE EOWN FMT X JUMPEEI O AER TIEE LAZY DON =59 or 47%
AHE T TUICK SROITN ROX J TMPEDOEAER THE LAZY DOG HE QUIBK BA OWN S EONT W UN PED D I TEE E TH LAZY DOG T S QUIEIEK T EE EOWN FMT X JUMPEEI O AER TIEE LAZY DON =56 or 42%
THE T TUICK SROITN ROX J TMPED OEAER THE LAZY DOG HE QUIBK BA OWN S EONT W UN PED D I TEE E TH LAZY DOG TES QUIEIEK T EE EOWN FMT X JUMPEEI O AER TIEE LAZY DON =55 or 42%
over all average is 44%
DM780
*HE TUUICK *RON <VE>OX J VMPED JVER THE LAZY DOG THE UICK BROWN*IOX WEUDPED JVEEI ETHE *AZY DOG UHE SQUI*K TIROWN FOX JUMPEB EO UER AHE *AZY ELOME =39 or 30%
*HE TUUICK *RON <VE>OX J UMPED JVEEI THE LAZY OG AHE QUICK BROWN*IOX WEUDPED OVEEI AHE *AZY DOG AHE *UI*K UIROWN FOX JUMPEB EO UER AHE *AZY DOG =37 or 28%
*HE TUUICK *RON *OX J AMPED JVER THE LAZY DOG AHE EUICK BROWN*OX WEUDPED OVEEI AHE ILAZY DOG THE SQUI6K AIROWN FOX JUMPEB EJ UER THE *AZY ELOZ =32 or 24%
over all average is 27%
FlDigi
THE T TUICN BROETN ROX J TMPED OEAEEI TSE LI ZY DE TG THE MTUIBK DTEOWN HT TX W UTPE S NUEEI TH R AG Y DONE T S QUE HM TEROW I
UN X JU EP E O AER TIEE LAZY D WN =71 or 54%
5HE T TUICN BROETN ROX J TMPED OEAEEI TSE LI ZY DE TG THE MTUIBK DTEOWN HT TX W UTPE I NUEEI TH R AG Y DONE T S QUE HM TEROW I
UN X JU EP E O AER TIEE LAZY D W = 70 or 53%
5HE T TUICN BROETN ROX J TMPED OEAEEI TSE LI ZY DE TG THE MTUIBK DTEOWN HT TX W UTPE S NUEEI TH R AG Y DONE T S QUE HM TEROW I
UN X JU EP E O AER TIEE LAZY D W =70 or 53%
over all average is 53%
MultiPSK
THE TEEEEETETETET TSROEETN ROX J TMPED OEER THE LAZY DMG HE QIICK BAETMWTE &MTTEA W UNEPEOETH LAY DOG TSE QUIEK NIOWN UETX JUMPE I O AER TIE LAZY DOM =66 or 50%
TIEET EEEEETETETET TSAEOEETN ROX J TMPED OEETHE LAZY DTMG THE QIICK BAETMWTE FOTEA W UNEPED OIER TH LAY DOG TSE QUIEK NIOWN UETX JUMPE EE O AER TIEE LAZY DOM =71 or 54%
TIET T EEEEEETETET TSROEETN ROX J TMPED OEETHE LAZY DTMG THE QITICK BAETMWN &OTEA W UNEWEED MTIER TH LAY DOG TSE QUIEK NIOWN UETX JUMPE EE O AER TIEE LAZY DOM =69 or 52%
over all average is 52%
mrp40
THe Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog
THe Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog
THe Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog The Quick Brown FOX Jumped Over The Lazy Dog
over all score 0%
8,13,18,27wpm in order percent of errors for direct path -3db snr
18,13wpm mid latitude -3db snr
8wpm mid latitude +4db SNR
I combined the results of the 8wpm into the grand total of direct and mid latitude average
MixW
9
16
17
9
=13%
66
82
=74%
=44%
total of mids
=64
Grand total
=39%
MultiPSK
3
0
0
0
=.75%
24
45
= 35%
=52% 8wpm mid
44% mid combined
grand total 22%
DM780
25
8
0
2
=9%
46
64
=55%
=27%
mid latitude combined
41%
grand total
25%
FLDigi
3
.33
0
0
=2%
40
49
=45%
=53%
combined mid
49%
grandtotal
26%
MRP40
0
0
0
21
=5%
54
66
=60%
combined mid
30%
grand total
18%
CWget
3
5
0
5
=3%
Ranking for direct path -3db snr over all average of different speeds of 27,18,13,8wpm below is in order from best to worse
MultiPSK
FLDigi
CWGet
MRP40
DM780
MixW
Ranking for mid latitude quiet -3db snr over all average of 18,13wpm in order from best to worse
MultiPSK
FLDigi
DM780
MRP40
MixW
Ranking with results of 8wpm mid lattitude +4db snr in order best to worse
MRP40
DM780
MixW
MultiPSK
FLDigi
Ranking for grand total of all tests with the 8wpm mid combined from best to worse
MRP40
MultiPSK
DM780
FLdigi
MixW
From this test I can see there is a trend , It seems most of the software struggle with slower CW speeds, maybe due to noise inbetween characters? All software seemed to do better with mid speeds of 13 and 18wpm but then going to the 27wpm the errors start to increase again, also the same trend can be seen when there is multipath introduced, some software unknown to me and handle multipath better than others and some softwares are just more sensitive to dig out characters through the noise. MRP40 seems to be the most sensitive and over all the best with multipath even though it suffered the worst at higher speeds.
